modern-to-grade · holo
Carmine
Twilight Masquerade · #204 · English · released 2024
Raw market price
$5.1
7 days
▲ 1.7%
30 days
▼ 18.4%
90 days
▼ 39.2%
Graded prices & PSA population
| Grade | Market price | PSA population |
|---|---|---|
| PSA 10 | $45 | 438 |
| PSA 9 | $20 | 379 |
| PSA 8 | $10 | 46 |
PSA population recorded 2026-07-20 · total graded 883
Why this card matters
pop
380 raw listings is a crowded market, graded sample sizes are tiny (n=5 PSA10) making the premium look large but fragile, and the raw-to-PSA10 multiplier of ~9x is modest for a true scarce card.
demand
Carmine is a recognizable Pokémon character but lacks the deep nostalgia or competitive meta relevance needed to drive sustained collector demand, and the -6.7% 30-day momentum signals softening interest.
artist
The holo Ultra Rare treatment gives it above-average visual appeal, but without a standout illustrator credit or alt-art designation it sits firmly in the middle tier of desirability.
catalyst
Negative 30-day price momentum of -6.7% with no upcoming set rotation, reprint threat, or tournament relevance provides no identifiable near-term catalyst to reverse the slide.
Graded comps on record
$58
CGC 10
$45
PSA 10
$33
BGS 9
$20
PSA 9
$17
CGC 10
$11
SGC 10
Track Carmine in the app.
Daily recorded prices, PSA pop history, price alerts and 7,300+ more cards to discover — free, coming soon to the App Store.
More from Twilight Masquerade
Market data recorded recently from licensed market sources. MASTER records prices daily and never invents a number — estimated values are always labeled. Not financial advice.