modern-to-grade · special illustration
Carmine
Twilight Masquerade · #217 · English · released 2024
Raw market price
$55
7 days
▲ 0.2%
30 days
▲ 0.8%
90 days
▼ 26.7%
Graded prices & PSA population
| Grade | Market price | PSA population |
|---|---|---|
| PSA 10 | $136 | 3,990 |
| PSA 9 | $74 | 3,414 |
| PSA 8 | $59 | 673 |
PSA population recorded 2026-09-05 · total graded 8,272
Why this card matters
pop
213 listings signals moderate supply, and the PSA 10 graded premium over raw is meaningful but undermined by PSA 10s ($70) trading *below* recent sold comps ($172), suggesting inconsistent liquidity rather than true scarcity.
demand
Carmine is a popular rival character with solid fan appeal, but she lacks the deep nostalgia pull of legacy Pokémon characters, keeping demand steady rather than exceptional.
artist
The Special Illustration Rare treatment delivers the expressive, painterly alt-art style collectors actively seek in Twilight Masquerade, giving this card genuine illustration desirability.
catalyst
11.5% 30-day momentum is modest and the sharp dislocation between current PSA 10 listings ($70) and recent sold comps ($172) raises red flags about data reliability or a stale ask pile, not a clean bullish signal.
Graded comps on record
$299
CGC 10
$191
TAG 10
$136
PSA 10
$103
SGC 10
$100
ACE 10
$92
BGS 9.5
Track Carmine in the app.
Daily recorded prices, PSA pop history, price alerts and 7,300+ more cards to discover — free on the App Store now.
More from Twilight Masquerade
Market data recorded 2026-09-05 from licensed market sources. MASTER records prices daily and never invents a number — estimated values are always labeled. Not financial advice.